Angelo Mozilo’s SEC Victory
Angelo Mozilo must be feeling pretty good these days. The guy with the perpetual tan earned well over a half billion dollars transforming Countrywide Financial into one of the nation’s leading mortgage lenders and then ran it into the ground by saddling the company with dubious mortgages that nearly led to the country’s ruin. And what is his SEC punishment for alleged insider trading and misleading shareholders?
A $67.5 million fine, of which about one-third will be paid by Countrywide’s acquirer, Bank of America, along with his legal fees. What’s more, Mozilo didn’t even have to admit any wrongdoing. In Wall Street parlance, he made one heck of a trade.
Yes, Mozilo also was banned for life from serving as an officer or director of a company, but given his track record and the fact he’s 71, his career working at public companies was pretty much over to begin with. Managing his hefty billion dollar portfolio should keep him pretty busy, particularly if Mozilo wants to judiciously avoid public companies managed by greedy executives like himself who put their interests ahead of shareholders.
By any measure, Mozilo’s penalty amounts to a wrist slap and will hardly serve as a deterrent. And the sad truth is the SEC can hardly be faulted for letting Mozilo off virtually scott free. The agency simply doesn’t have the resources to take on companies or individuals with extensive means. Prosecuting Mozilo would have been a formidable and high risk challenge; even if the agency garnered a win in court — and a victory was far from assured — he has the means to file appeals and drag the case on for years. Ditto for Goldman Sachs, which the SEC let off for a measly $550 million fine for securities fraud and no required admission of wrongdoing.
Admittedly, Mozilo still reportedly faces possible criminal charges and federal prosecutors have the talent and wherewithal to go the distance with Mozilo’s legal army. If prosecutors do bring charges, let’s hope they do a better job convincing a jury than they did prosecuting Ralph R. Cioffi and Matthew M. Tannin.
In the meantime, Mozilo can continue enjoying the good life with his Wall Street enablers. Sadly, there is no public shame being accused of wrongdoing by the SEC. Despite charges that ultimately led to a $6 million fine and a two-year ban from the securities industry for his role in a pay-to-play scandal involving New York State’s pension fund, former Quadrangle Group head Steven Rattner was feted last week at a reception attended by an impressive bevy of bold-faced names.
People with power on Wall Street don’t take the SEC all that seriously. The Goldman and Mozilo settlements give them ample reason not to.
Jacob ("Jake") H. Zamansky is one of the country’s foremost authorities on securities arbitration law, the legal recourse for investors claiming broker wrongdoing, or for brokers claiming wrongful termination or other misconduct by their employer. Zamansky & Associates, the New York-based law firm he founded, represents both individuals and institutions in complex securities, hedge fund, and employment arbitrations.
COMMENT ON THIS BLOG POST
Or contact Jake Zamansky privately